When Englisch artist Penelope Moore arrives in the tiny town of Pierce, Montana, she isn't sure what to expect. But it isn't her twin sister! She's stunned by the similarities between herself and bed-and-breakfast owner Simon Troyer's sister-in-law, then the truth comes to light: she and Sarah were separated at birth. Soon Penelope is welcomed into the Amish community with open arms. And the more time she spends with the Amish bachelor Simon, the more she rethinks her life in the Englisch world. But will she still be accepted when they all discover why she's really in Montana?